05 Nov 2023
CIH response to government proposals to criminalise the use of tents by people rough sleeping
CIH has joined with the top 15 charities and organisations from across homelessness and housing in an open letter to government on 5 November urging them to reconsider its proposed homelessness legislation to ban tents. The letter, coordinated by Shelter, states the ban will costs lives and lead to “totally preventable” street deaths, instead the letter advocates for government to focus on genuine solutions that will better support homeless people and prevent homelessness from happening in the first place.
Gavin Smart CIH chief executive commented:
“Homelessness, presented in its sharpest form as rough sleeping, is not a lifestyle choice. It is increasing across the country in all forms (on the streets, in B&Bs, hostels, sofa surfing etc.) as we don’t have enough affordable homes for people to live in and the cost of living crisis is exacerbating structural issues.
“The data is clear. Private rents are increasing at unprecedented levels, with local housing allowance rates frozen at 2020 amounts which creates an ever-growing affordability gap. Housing supply is not keeping pace with need and has not done so for decades. This is a housing crisis which requires positive state intervention - the answer is not to blame the victims and punish those trying to help them which will only make things worse.
“We need an evidence based long-term plan for housing which addresses housing need and supports people on lower incomes. This must be underpinned by an effective social security system. We've set out more detail on this in our housing strategy.
“We call on the government to use the upcoming King’s speech and Autumn Statement to take constructive action and to work with partners in trying to address the heartbreaking situation that is homelessness in the 21st century.”
CIH are a member of the Rural Homeless Counts Coalition, who also sent an open letter to government, on November 6, voicing deep concerns over the Home Secretary's statements about criminalising the use of tenants by homeless people.
Open letter to Home Secretary Suella Braverman on government proposals to criminalise the use of tents by people sleeping rough
5 November 2023
Dear Home Secretary,
cc Michael Gove, Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities
As organisations supporting people experiencing homelessness, we are writing to ask you to urgently reconsider proposals to criminalise the use of tents by people sleeping rough as a replacement for the draconian 1824 Vagrancy Act.
Working on the frontline of the homelessness crisis, we know all too well the risk to life these punitive laws present, and how they only serve to push people further into destitution. We are calling for an urgent reversal of this decision if the government wants to prevent people from dying on our streets, exposed to the cold and all the hardship that rough sleeping entails.
Sleeping on the street is not a lifestyle choice. Laying blame with people forced to sleep rough will only push people further away from help into poverty, putting them at risk of exploitation. At the extreme end we will see an increase in deaths and fatalities which are totally preventable.
People sleeping rough frequently experience violence and abuse. The impact on their physical and mental health is significant. The average age of death for people experiencing homelessness is just 45 for men and 43 for women. This is not a life people choose.
There is much more that can be done to tackle rough sleeping, and ending it for good is completely achievable. We urge you to focus on housing solutions to prevent homelessness and rough sleeping, investing in interventions like Housing First which helps people into safe, secure housing combined with wraparound services so people can remain off the streets. These are models that are proven to work.
In the short-term, increasing housing benefit at the Autumn Statement so people can afford their rent must also be part of the solution. Alongside this, there needs to be a reversal of the recent changes to asylum-seeker policy which are resulting in people granted settled status being evicted within a matter of days, pushing them into rough sleeping and other forms of homelessness.
We strongly urge you to reconsider these measures, which will result in harm to thousands of people who have no option but to sleep in a tent, or on the streets, as they have no home of their own. Removing the only protection many people depend on and endangering lives cannot be the answer. We remain willing to work with you and the government on genuine solutions to end rough sleeping for good, but these changes gravely undermine any efforts to do so.
Kind regards,
Matt Downie MBE, CEO, Crisis
Gavin Smart, CEO, Chartered Institute of Housing
Seyi Obakin OBE, CEO, Centrepoint
Katie Dalton, Director, Cymorth Cymru
Jean Templeton, CEO, St Basils and Chair of the WMCA Homelessness Taskforce
Rick Henderson, CEO, Homeless Link
Kate Henderson, CEO, National Housing Federation
Alex Bax, CEO, Pathway
Pam Orchard, CEO, The Connection at St Martin in the Fields
Mick Clarke, CEO, The Passage
Emma Haddad, CEO, St Mungo’s
Michael Chandler, CEO, Groundswell
Bridget Young, Director, NACCOM
Amanda Dubarry, CEO, Your Place
Enver Solomon, CEO, The Refugee Council
